Extreme sports are all about pushing the boundaries of human limits, whether it’s free-falling from a plane or leaping off a bridge with only a cord tied to your ankles. Among the many adrenaline-packed activities, two of the most popular are bungee jumping and skydiving. Both offer a thrill like no other, but for many, the question of safety often arises: Which is safer, bungee jumping or skydiving?
In this article, we will explore the safety measures, risks, and statistics surrounding these two extreme sports to help you make an informed decision.
What Is Bungee Jumping?
Bungee jumping is an activity where a person jumps from a great height, typically from a bridge or crane, while connected to a large elastic cord. The thrill comes from the free-fall and the rapid deceleration when the cord stretches to its limit. The jumper is then pulled back upwards before falling again. This cyclical motion continues until the cord’s energy is spent.
Bungee jumping has its roots in the indigenous practices of the people of Vanuatu, where young men would leap from high platforms with vines tied around their ankles. Today, it is a widely popular sport, with jumps occurring worldwide at varying altitudes, from bridges over rivers to purpose-built towers.
Safety Measures in Bungee Jumping
Bungee jumping is considered a relatively safe extreme sport when the proper safety procedures are followed. The essential safety equipment includes:
Elastic Cord: The cord must be strong enough to support the weight of the jumper and ensure they are decelerated safely. Most cords are made of high-quality latex and are tested for durability.
Harness and Straps: Jumpers are harnessed to the bungee cord via strong straps, typically around the waist or chest, to ensure they remain secure during the jump.
Pre-Jump Checks: Jumping operations usually involve strict checks for both equipment and the jumper’s weight. Each jumper’s weight is recorded to ensure that the cord is correctly chosen for their body weight.
Instructor Supervision: A trained instructor is always on hand to ensure the safety of the participant. They verify the equipment and conduct a thorough safety briefing before the jump.
Emergency Procedures: In rare cases of accidents, bungee jumping sites will have medical teams on standby and well-established emergency protocols.
What Is Skydiving?
Skydiving involves jumping out of an aircraft at high altitude and free-falling before deploying a parachute to slow the descent and land safely. The thrill of skydiving comes not only from the free fall but also from the spectacular views experienced during the descent. Depending on the altitude, skydiving can involve jumping from anywhere between 10,000 and 14,000 feet, with some extreme jumpers reaching higher altitudes.
Skydiving has evolved significantly over the years, with modern parachutes designed for both safety and ease of control. Today, there are various types of skydiving, including tandem jumps (where the participant is attached to an experienced instructor) and solo jumps (for licensed skydivers).
Safety Measures in Skydiving
Skydiving is generally considered a safe sport, but like any extreme activity, it does involve certain risks. The safety measures in skydiving include:
Parachutes: Modern skydiving parachutes are designed to deploy quickly and safely. Skydivers wear a main parachute and a reserve parachute, which is deployed if the main chute fails.
Automatic Activation Device (AAD): An AAD is a safety device that automatically deploys the reserve parachute if the skydiver reaches a certain altitude and has not yet deployed their chute. This adds an extra layer of safety for solo jumpers.
Training and Licensing: To skydive solo, a person must undergo comprehensive training to learn how to operate the parachute, manage free-fall positions, and understand emergency procedures. This training typically takes about 25-30 jumps over a period of weeks.
Instructor Supervision: For tandem jumps, an instructor is always present to control the jump. Tandem instructors are highly trained and undergo rigorous safety protocols.
Equipment Checks: Both the main and reserve parachutes are checked before every jump. Experienced skydivers and instructors will also ensure that harnesses and other equipment are secure and functional.
Comparing Safety: Bungee Jumping Vs. Skydiving
Statistical Safety Record
Both bungee jumping and skydiving are generally considered to be safe extreme sports when conducted under professional supervision and with proper equipment. However, when looking at accident statistics, the risks involved in these activities differ.
Bungee Jumping: According to the National Association for Bungee Jumping (NABJ) and various other safety agencies, the injury rate for bungee jumping is extremely low. With proper safety measures in place, the risk of death is rare. In fact, statistics indicate that only a handful of fatal accidents have occurred worldwide since bungee jumping became popular in the 1980s. Most injuries are minor, often involving strains or sprains due to the deceleration of the jump.
Skydiving: The United States Parachute Association (USPA) maintains detailed statistics on skydiving safety. According to their reports, the fatality rate in skydiving is about 1 in 11,000 jumps. While this rate is considered low, it is higher than that of bungee jumping. Most injuries in skydiving occur during the landing phase, as landing with a parachute requires skill and judgment. However, the development of modern parachuting technology and better training has significantly reduced the number of fatalities and serious injuries.
Risk of Equipment Failure
Both sports involve equipment that must perform flawlessly for the safety of the participant.
Bungee Jumping: The primary piece of equipment in bungee jumping is the bungee cord. The risk of equipment failure is low, but in the event of an issue, such as a malfunctioning cord or harness, the jumper could face serious injury. Proper maintenance, weight checks, and safety procedures significantly reduce this risk. In fact, most deaths associated with bungee jumping occur due to human error, such as incorrect weight measurement or improper harness fitting.
Skydiving: The equipment in skydiving—primarily the parachute—also comes with a small risk of failure. However, modern parachutes are designed with redundancy: the reserve chute provides an additional layer of safety if the primary chute fails. While parachute failures do occur, they are exceedingly rare. In the event of a malfunction, skydivers are trained to respond quickly, deploying the reserve chute or utilizing an AAD.
Although parachute failure is less common, when it does occur, the consequences can be severe if not addressed immediately.
Physical Stress and Health Risks
Both bungee jumping and skydiving place physical stress on the body, though the types of strain differ.
Bungee Jumping: The main physical stress in bungee jumping comes from the rapid deceleration as the cord stretches and then recoils. This can cause strain on the joints, especially the knees and back. For those with heart conditions or high blood pressure, the sudden jolt could trigger an adverse event, so it’s recommended that people with these conditions avoid bungee jumping.
Skydiving: Skydiving places a different type of strain on the body, particularly during the free-fall phase. The body experiences high speeds (typically 120 mph during free fall), which can cause temporary discomfort in the ears, chest, and face. However, skydivers are typically in better physical condition due to the training required. Like bungee jumping, skydiving is not recommended for people with heart conditions or severe medical issues, particularly in solo jumping, where the physical demands are greater.
Conclusion
Both bungee jumping and skydiving are thrilling and relatively safe when proper safety procedures are followed. However, based on accident statistics, bungee jumping is generally considered to be safer than skydiving.
The number of fatalities in bungee jumping is extremely low compared to skydiving, where the fatality rate is higher, albeit still low. Skydiving also has more complex equipment and procedures, which introduces more opportunities for error, especially for solo jumpers.
Related topics:
